Oh, Mann

I’m not upset that you lied to me, I’m upset that from now on I can’t believe you

~ Friedrich Nietzsche

 

Michael E. Mann is distinguished professor of atmospheric science at Pennsylvania State University and director of the Penn State Earth System Science Center. I believe he’s also a liar, a claim for which I provide evidence in this essay. I suspect he’s a coward, too. If you prefer authority over evidence, this is not the essay for you. And Mann’s your man.

An episode of NBL radio focused on Mann’s work. As with all such shows, the subject was invited to participate. As with all such subjects, Mann failed to call in. December 2015 was a long time ago, and Mann has since written and said false things about me. Ergo the current critique.

Professor Mann knows what I know about abrupt climate change. He has participated in email exchanges involving Mann, Thom Hartmann, and me. I’ll not share the messages due to my sense of ethics and professional courtesy, the likes of which I rarely observe from others. And here’s a hint: Mann began borrowing from my work, without attribution, after the messages in question pointed to this blog. For example, he began speaking about global dimming after these email exchanges.

Mann continues to promulgate the 2 C myth, and I know he knows better. Two degrees Celsius above the 1750 baseline is a political target dreamed into existence by neoclassical economist William Nordhaus. Mann ignores the United Nations upper limit of 1 C above the 1750 baseline, as well as the 0.5 C target-in-the-rearview-mirror acknowledged by climate writer and speaker David Spratt in October 2014 (links to all cited works are included here). In addition, as a leading voice for the politically motivated Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, Mann ignores important self-reinforcing feedback loops. He commits “errors” and omits facts.

Dr. Mann was the senior author of
a commentary published 12 July 2017 in the Washington Post. It was penned in response to David Wallace-Wells’ 7,300-word feature article in New York magazine, a piece of writing that fails miserably to portray abrupt climate change as a serious threat and apparently was the most widely read article in the history of the magazine (likely because it fails miserably to portray abrupt climate change as a serious threat). The short, libelous piece of unintentional comedy by Mann and crew includes the following paragraph from the Post, a leading mouthpiece of American Empire:

“Some of the more egregious examples can be found among fringe characters such as ecologist Guy McPherson —- a doomist cult hero who insists that exponential climate change likely will render human beings and all other species extinct within 10 years.”

There are several errors in this one-sentence paragraph. I’ll focus upon three of the errors. Firstly, I’m hardly a fringe character. I’ve attracted the attention of most of the world’s climate scientists, the New York Times, and hundreds of other media outlets. Secondly, I’m not a doomist cult hero. Rather, and quite importantly considering the context, I’m a doomist cult superhero. Thirdly, Mann is lying: I’ve neither said nor written, “that exponential climate change likely will render human beings and all other species extinct within 10 years.” Not surprisingly for a man of his enormous –and seemingly unrecognized — privilege, Mann fails to distinguish between human life and all life on Earth. He repeats the libelous statement in an interview with The Real News Network.

Had I sufficient money and time, I would sue Mann and his co-authors for libel. I don’t have the imperialist deep pockets of Pennsylvania State University, much less a leading newspaper of record for the corrupt American press. As a result, the Washington Post and its writers are off the hook, as is often the case. I contacted the ACLU and other groups to request pro bono support. Alas, there’s little interest and no money in extinction.

I’ll finish this essay the same way I complete my public presentations: with unexpectedly good news for the audience. I am scheduled to appear with Professor Mann on a panel at the Geological Society of America’s 2017 annual meeting on 24 October of this year. That’s not the good news. This is: I don’t believe I will have the opportunity to document Mann’s lies before his colleagues. Instead, I strongly suspect I’ll be dead as a result of abrupt climate change, I’ll be uninvited, or Mann will demonstrate his cowardice by failing to show up for the panel.

If allowed, I’ll doubtless be among the very few participants at this meeting paying my own way. Taxpayers will be paying Mann to attend. If you’d like to help me make the trip, donations are welcome.

 

Crawford’s Attractions has created a crowd-funding initiative to support my upcoming tours. For details and to provide support, click here.

I’m tentatively scheduled to tour Ontario, Canada, in November 2017 with possible support from Sudbury, Hamilton, Montreal, and Ottawa. If you’d like to throw your hat into the ring, please send a message to booking@crawfordsattractions.com. To keep costs down, as part of this tour I am seeking hosts and venues in and near Burlington, Vermont.


I’ve launched a new video series, scheduled to air every Tuesday at 7:00 p.m. Eastern. Catch the Guy, Fawkes, and Jamen show here.

I’ve received recent requests for a workshop focused on emotions rather than evidence. Such a workshop is described here. It is available in your hometown and also in Belize.

I’m booking guests at the mud hut. For details, click here.

The next episode of NBL radio will air at 3:00 p.m. Eastern on Tuesday, 1 August 2017 at PRN.fm. Thanks for your patience. We will have a guest and we will take toll-free calls from listeners at 888.874.4888.

______

Catch Nature Bats Last on the radio with Cory Morningstar and Guy McPherson. To listen live, tune in the first Tuesday of each month at 3:00 p.m. Eastern time, or catch up in the archives here. If you prefer the iTunes version, including the option to subscribe, you can click here. We’re on Stitcher, too.

McPherson’s latest book is available in audio, and can be purchased here. Ms. Ladybug and Mr. Honeybee: A Love Story at the End of Time is intended for ages 11 and up.